Morning Report Excerpts - 1994
The Morning Report includes accidents and incidents in the National Park System. Here are reports I thought people might find interesting.
93-510 - Zion (Utah) - Follow-up on Rescue
On July 15, 1993, Dave Fleisher, 27, and Kim Ellis, 37, drowned in two
separate incidents about an hour apart on private property in Kolob Creek
adjacent to the park. The two victims, a surviving adult and five teen-age
Explorer Scouts were on a four-day hike which was scheduled to conclude in
the park on July 17th and had a permit for the last night of their trip
through Zion Narrows. After they were reported overdue, an extensive
helicopter search in very rugged terrain was initiated. The six survivors
were located and rescued on July 19th through a cooperative effort by
Washington County sheriff's officers and the park's SAR team. The body of
Kim Ellis was retrieved the same day; Fleisher's body was not located and
retrieved until ten days later because of extremely high, cold water and
steep narrow terrain. The latter recovery effort, directed by district
ranger Dave Buccello, was one of the most technically demanding and
hazardous retrievals undertaken by the combined county/park SAR team.
The
12-day incident generated over 300 media inquiries, including live TV
coverage from five stations in Las Vegas and Salt Lake City, and made the
1993 top ten story list for two of the three network affiliates in Salt Lake
City. On January 3rd, the park received multiple tort claims for millions
of dollars from attorneys representing families of both victims and
survivors and passed them on to DOI's solicitor in Salt Lake City. The
solicitor's office has up to six months to rule on the case. Attorneys for
the families filed copies of the claims directly with the Utah media, which
has generated many additional inquiries to the park. Media reports also
indicate that the families are working with a movie studio on the
development of a feature film. [Denny Davies, PIO, ZION, 1/7]
More info: High Country News Article.
94-28 - Arches (Utah) - Paleontological/Minerals Theft Investigation
Arches rangers have been involved in a nine-month-long multi-agency
investigation of the theft of paleontological and mineral resources from
state-owned lands just west of the park. Based on information received last
spring, rangers contacted four individuals - longtime Moab rock shop owner,
fossil hunter and Canyonlands concessioner Lin Ottinger; Ottinger's female
companion; and Doran and Eileen Wade of Rock Springs, Wyoming - who were
excavating dinosaur bones and chert in the Dalton Wells area. After
obtaining consent, a search of the Wades' vehicle revealed dinosaur bones
which had been collected at this site. Subsequent investigations by Arches
rangers, BLM rangers and Grand County sheriff's officers resulted in state
charges being filed against Ottinger and the Wades. Charges for theft of
paleontological resources were quickly dismissed by the county judge, who
unfortunately was unaware of the precedent-setting nature of the citations
issued - the first known citations invoking the state's relatively recent
paleontological protection act. The state proceeded with charges against
Ottinger in district court, contending that he had collected mineral
resources from state land without a permit. The case will go to trial this
spring. This is the first time such a case involving protection of mineral
resources has been taken to district court in Utah. [CRO, ARCH, 1/14]
93-142 - Dinosaur (Colorado/Utah) - ARPA Conviction
In June of 1992, NPS rangers, BLM investigators, and local law enforcement
officers following up on some information provided by an informant
discovered an excavated archeological site on federal land near Vernal,
Utah. The persons suspected of looting the site - Wilma and Ricky Brooks of
Vernal, Utah - had been under surveillance for similar depredations in the
park and elsewhere on federal lands in the area. The informant also told
officers that the couple had removed a cradleboard with the mummified
remains of a Fremont Indian infant from the site, and that he had seen it at
their residence. On March 17th, federal agents arrested the pair for the
theft, and they were subsequently indicted in federal district court for
various ARPA violations. The remains, which date from around 650 A.D., were
the first such found in the Uintah Basin.
In 1993, the Brooks each pled
guilty to one felony ARPA violation under a plea agreement. On March 8th,
they were sentenced to five years' supervised probation and ten months' in
home confinement (with all their activities monitored electronically), fined
$1,100 for restitution and repatriation, and ordered to forfeit a 1989 Ford
pickup. They were not required, however, to pay the $10,000 cost of the
investigation and site excavation. The judge's comments during sentencing
were interesting in that the Brooks' defense attorney maintained that his
clients should receive light sentences because there was no real victim nor
did the baby have any family ties to modern times. The judge stated that
the baby was indeed a victim, that the baby had obviously had a caring
family who had wrapped and buried him/her, and that the baby was
exceptionally vulnerable to this type of crime. The judge also stated that
he believed the testimony from Ute and Hopi witnesses who linked the Fremont
culture to their nations through oral histories. [Dan Moses, CR, NP-DINO, 3/9]
92-70 - Glen Canyon (Utah/Arizona) - Follow-up on ARPA Incident
On February 29, 1992, rangers discovered that 21 petroglyphs in the Mobius
panel in Willow Gulch on the Escalante River had been seriously damaged.
The petroglyphs, dating to about 950 to 1150 A.D., are part of a "billboard"
of over 100 elements which is considered to be a highly significant
scientific resource eligible for the national register. The panel is one of
only a few such panels found in all of the Escalante canyons. The
petroglyphs were damaged by scraping, which was apparently done with a sharp
instrument to enhance them so they would show up better in photographs.
Natural varnish was removed in the process and the petroglyphs' shapes were
altered through careless tracing of the original outlines.
On March 10th,
McKay Bailey of Escalante, Utah, pled guilty to the destruction of the
petroglyphs. As part of his plea agreement, Bailey agreed that the
archeological value of the panel he damaged was $21,745; he also agreed to
forfeit his 1990 Ford 4x4 pickup, and to reimburse the NPS $2,846 for
restoration and repair of the site and $2,970 for direct government
expenses. In exchange for this plea, the government has agreed to recommend
a $1,000 fine and dismiss the second count in the indictment for destruction
of government property. Sentencing is scheduled for June. In a televised
interview, Bailey's attorney stated that the case had cost his client
$25,000 and that Bailey had gotten the message of the importance of
protecting archeological resources on federal lands. [Tomie Lee, CR, GLCA,
3/16]
94-129 - Glen Canyon (Utah) - Felony Pursuit; Search; Arrests
On Tuesday, March 16th, rangers at Halls Crossing received a call advising
that a red Toyota Four Runner with two male and two female occupants had
driven off from a local gas station without paying for $17 worth of fuel.
Rangers pursued, at one point closing to within a mile of the vehicle.
Despite their best efforts, however, they were unable to get any closer.
The suspects apparently did not know that they were being followed. When it
became apparent that the pursuit would lead out of the park, county deputies
were notified and assistance was sought from rangers at Natural Bridges.
Before the vehicle reached their roadblock, the occupants decided to turn
off onto a gravel road leading into a remote historical mining area. Having
already passed the road, however, they turned around to drive a mile back;
they then discovered that rangers were pursuing them and took off cross
country in an effort to reach the dirt road. They were again able to elude
their pursuers, and their dust cloud showed that they were getting further
away. When the rangers rounded a particularly sharp corner, they found a
fresh set of tracks leading off the road and over a 300-foot cliff into the
canyon below. Debris scattered along the fall line confirmed that the
vehicle had gone over the edge, although the Toyota couldn't be seen from
the top. Pat Horning, the first ranger to reach the car, reported that
there were no occupants within, and ranger Steve Luckesen discovered
footprints leading uphill from the road, indicating that the occupants had
gotten out of the car before it went over the edge. The park plane assisted
in the subsequent search for the foursome, which was conducted by rangers
(including ranger Jim Ireland from Natural Bridges), Utah Highway Patrol
officers, San Juan county deputies, a Utah wildlife officer and an FBI
agent. Ranger Russ Miller tracked the four youths to their hiding spot
several hundred yards upslope. Three were found to be juveniles; the fourth
was 19 years old. They'd stolen the car from a dealership in Murray, Utah,
then had decided to take a camping trip into the desert. The vehicle was a
total loss. All suspects were taken into custody by Utah Highway Patrol
officers. [Tomie Lee, CR, GLCA, 3/23]
94-153 - Capitol Reef (Utah) - Search
The park received a report of an overdue party of 16 Boy Scouts and two
leaders around 9 p.m. on March 31st. The party had been on a hike up Burrow
Wash, a rugged canyon with numerous narrows and pools of water. At the time
of their departure, temperatures were in the 60s and many of the scouts were
reportedly wearing T-shirts and shorts. Temperatures were forecast to drop
in the upper 20s that night. A hasty search was conducted, but searchers
were unable to locate the party. An air and ground search was begun at dawn
the next morning. The group was located south of the canyon at 11 a.m.
They'd built a fire and managed to stay warm , and all were reportedly okay.
[Rick Nolan, CR, CARE, 4/1]
94-173 - Arches (Utah) - Multiple Incidents
During the month-long period ending April 8th, the park's small staff were
involved in four technical rescues, including one major rescue requiring the
help of two Canyonlands rangers; three searches; four medicals involving
transport to the hospital; four motor vehicle accidents, including a DUI and
a rollover with four injuries and two trapped inside; and numerous minor law
enforcement and traffic offenses. These incidents correspond to a
significant increase in visitation (up 30% by the end of March) associated
with the Moab area becoming a destination for college and high school
students on spring breaks. During the same period, the park implemented a
mandatory permit system for day hikers in Fiery Furnace, a popular but
delicate sandstone fin area that has seen severe resource degradation in the
last few years because of unregulated and uneducated users. [Jim Webster,
CR, ARCH, 4/10]
94-313 - Glen Canyon (Utah) - Memorial Day Incidents
Although there appeared to be fewer visitors this year to Hobie Cat and Lone
Rock beaches - the two beaches that are traditional problem areas on
Memorial Day weekend - parkwide visitation and law enforcement incidents
were up over 1993. A good indicator of that increase was the level of
activity in the dispatch office. Dispatch averaged an outgoing radio
transmission every 60 seconds, with incoming calls often covering each
other, and averaged one incoming or outgoing phone call every three minutes.
There were 43 EMS incidents, 19 accidents requiring investigation, and a
high volume of law enforcement incidents, including a rape, eight assaults,
105 alcohol-related incidents, 46 cases of drunk driving, 20 disorderly
conducts, 179 traffic offenses, 141 boating offenses, and 86 drug incidents.
Overall, rangers made 98 arrests and issued 270 citations. The park's 20
commissioned rangers were augmented by officers from the Coconino and Kane
County sheriff's offices, Utah state police, Utah state park rangers,
Arizona game and fish officers, Coast Guard auxiliary, U.S. Park Police
officers, and rangers detailed to the park from other NPS areas. Volunteers
and park interpretive rangers assisted in directing traffic, parking
vehicles, and helping out at launch ramps. [Tomie Lee, CR, GLCA, 6/17]
93-510 - Zion (Utah) - Follow-up on Search and Rescue Incident
On June 20th, the Department of Interior solicitor in Salt Lake City denied
the $20 million plus tort claim filed last January as a result of two
fatalities and personal injuries which occurred in accidents on the north
boundary of the park on July 15, 1993. On that date, Dave Fleisher, 27, and
Kim Ellis, 37, drowned in two separate incidents about an hour apart on
private property in Kolob Creek adjacent to the park. The two victims, a
surviving adult and five teen-age Explorer Scouts were on a four-day hike
which was scheduled to conclude in the park on July 17th and had a permit
for the last night of their trip through Zion Narrows. After they were
reported overdue, an extensive helicopter search in very rugged terrain was
initiated. The six survivors were located and rescued on July 19th through
a cooperative effort by Washington County sheriff's officers and the park's
SAR team. On January 3rd, the park received multiple tort claims for
millions of dollars from attorneys representing families of both victims and
survivors and passed them on to the solicitor. On instructions from the
solicitor, the park is releasing no information and media inquiries are
being directed to his office for response. A suit in district court is
possible. [Denny Davies, PIO, ZION, 6/29]
More info: High Country News Article.
94-369 - Glen Canyon (Utah/Arizona) - Diving Fatality
Around noon on July 4th, Clinton Davison, 16, a citizen of Great Britain,
dove off a cliff face at a height of 150 feet and suffered major trauma to
his head upon striking the surface of the lake. Park medics and Classic
Life Guard helicopters responded. Davison was flown immediately to
Flagstaff Medical Center for treatment. On July 6th, Davison's family
decided to have him removed from life support due to the severity of his
brain injury. [Tomie Patrick Lee, CR, GLCA, 7/7]
94-370 - Glen Canyon (Utah/Arizona) - Drowning
James Jorgenson, 41, of Page, Arizona, drowned in the Coves area at Wahweap
on July 6th. Jorgenson was swimming with his 14-year-old son, ten-year-old
daughter and four neighborhood children when one of the neighbors, a ten-year-old girl,
tried to swim to a buoy field which was beyond her abilities.
Jorgenson saw that she was in trouble and attempted to swim to her rescue;
two men on shore also swam to her and were able to reach her as she was
going under and bring her to shore. No one realized Jorgenson was in
trouble, however, and he was not missed for some time. Rangers recovered
him from 42 feet of water about 100 feet from shore. Resuscitation efforts
were unsuccessful. [Tomie Patrick Lee, CR, GLCA, 7/7]
94-387 - Glen Canyon (Utah/Arizona) - Rescue
Rangers in the Hite Subdistrict responded to two medical incidents requiring
rescues in the Dark Canyon primitive area last week. Both incidents
involved members of The Road Less Traveled, a Chicago-based wilderness
adventure group. At 3 a.m. on July 6th, a 15-year-old female with severe
abdominal pain was evacuated to a hospital in Farmington, New Mexico, where
doctors determined that she had a ruptured ovarian cyst and bladder
infection. At 7 a.m. on the 7th, a 15-year-old male from the same group
became disoriented and unable to walk. Rangers treated him for dehydration
and hypoglycemia at the scene, then had him air evacuated to Farmington. In
both cases, rangers who are also parkmedics administered Ivs and medication
according to established protocols. [Tomie Lee, CR, GLCA, 7/7]
94-393 - Glen Canyon (Utah/Arizona) - SAR; Fatality
On July 15th, rangers in the Uplake District received sketchy, third-hand
information about a six-year-old boy who had reportedly been missing from
his camp in the vicinity of Halls Crossing for over an hour and a half. The
rangers soon arrived at the point the child had last been seen and initiated
a search which utilized protection and interpretive rangers and maintenance
staff. Within 45 minutes, four patrol boats, several park and local
aircraft and a state ranger were brought into the search effort. The
child's body was found on a mesa about a mile and a half above his family's
campsite approximately 90 minutes after the original report was received.
The child had followed other children to the mesa and had told them he was
going to return to camp. He was wearing only swimming shorts and sandals
and had no water. The air temperature at the time was 107 degrees, but
ground temperatures were much higher. Indications are that he became
disoriented and hyperthermic. A CISD team from Zion conducted a critical
stress debriefing later that day. [Tomie Lee, CR, GLCA, 7/15]
94-400 - Zion (Utah) - MVA with Fatality
Around 10 p.m. on July 16th, Marco Dyer of St. George, Utah, was westbound
on the park entrance road when he lost control of his motorcycle and
collided with the south wall of the Zion-Mt. Carmel tunnel. Dyer was
pulseless, apnic and had fixed and dilated pupils when park medics arrived.
Aggressive efforts to resuscitate him proved fruitless, and a doctor at
Dixie Regional Medical Center subsequently ordered them to cease their
efforts. [Dave Buccello, DR, Frontcountry District, ZION, 7/18]
94-439 - Capitol Reef (Utah) - Rescue
On July 28th, eight-year-old Jered Curtis of Nephi, Utah, wandered away from
a large group while hiking on the Hickman Bridge trail and became lost.
Curtis decided to climb down a 500-foot cliff to a highway he saw below; he
descended most of the cliff face successfully, but then fell and slid until
he lodged in a tiny pocket in the sandstone 70 feet above the bottom of the
cliff. A passing motorist heard the boy's calls for help. Ranger Tom Cox
ran to the base of the wall and calmed the boy for over two hours while
rescue teams scrambled over rough terrain to a point above him. During that
period, Cox was joined by the boy's father and a doctor. Rangers Scott
Brown and Garry Olson rappelled to Curtis, picked him off his perch, and
descended to his waiting parents. Except for some abrasions, the boy was
uninjured. At times, the highway shoulder was lined with vehicles, as over
200 people watched the rescue. [CRO, CARE, 7/31]
94-459 - Glen Canyon (Arizona/Utah) - Significant Assist to Agency
On August 12th, the park received a request from the Kane County sheriff's
office for assistance with a fight involving shots fire and wounded victims
in Big Water, Utah, a small unincorporated town on the park's southwest
boundary, as it would take their officers 20 to 30 minutes to reach the
scene. Additional reports indicated that one victim had been shot in the
head, and that a person was standing on his porch with a high-powered rifle,
threatening to kill anyone who came after him. Responding rangers and park
medics confronted James White, 30, who put his rifle down inside the house
as soon as they arrived and surrendered without further incident. They
found that he was had suffered head wounds from being struck in the head
with a pistol, and that Star Watson, 32, had been shot in the hand (not the
head) with a small caliber handgun. Watson, who has a lengthy criminal
file, was convicted of assault on a Glen Canyon ranger in 1990 and is
considered to be a high risk individual because of his expressed hatred for
law enforcement officers in general and rangers in particular. Kane County
deputies took both men into custody. Alcohol appears to have been a
contributing factor in the fight between the two men, who are neighbors.
[Tomie Lee, CR, GLCA, 8/15]
Zion NP (UT) - Fire Situation
The park had seven new lightning fires reported on the evening of
August 17th and the morning of the 18th, and another fire within a mile of
the park on private land protected by the county. Three fires were attached
on the 18th; one is out, and two were contained with the help of bucket
drops from BLM's Arizona Strip helicopter and two members of the helitack
crew. Three people hiked four miles down the West Rim trail and about a
half mile to the Rainbow fire to hold this fire at a quarter acre in heavy
fuels. Two firefighters were flown from the Detour fire, a seven-acre
carryover confinement wildfire, to the Hollow fire, also near the West Rim
trail, a major hiking route across the Horse Pasture Plateau. Two
additional firefighters were flown to the Sunrise fire, near the northeast
corner of the park. A fourth fire, the Dawn fire, burning in brush near an
isolated point above Goose Creek, was not attacked; smoke reappeared late in
the afternoon, and a crew was to hike out to it. Assistance of three
firefighters and a sawyer was requested from Bryce Canyon; these dropped
another snag on the MIA fire to assist Washington County. No smoke was seen
from the Cougar Mountain fire, the Greathart fire (which was two miles south
of the Detour fire and could also be managed in a confinement status), or
the Flicker fire, reported last night burning in manzanita. No smoke is
visible from the Detour fire, although some large dead and down material
continues to smolder within the burn. The BLM Automated Lightning Detection
System (ALDS) recorded approximately 200 strikes from the storm in the park
and nearby area.
94-557 - Glen Canyon (Utah/Arizona) - Falling Fatality
On the afternoon of September 15th, rangers received a cellular phone
request for medical assistance for a person with life-threatening injuries
who'd fallen from a cliff near the mouth of the Escalante arm of Lake
Powell. Upon arrival, they found that Paul Thompson, 51, of Dixon,
California, had already expired. Thompson was part of a group of seven BASE
jumpers who'd made several parachute jumps from the cliff face just south of
the Escalante confluence. Witnesses said that his chute deployed upon
jumping, but that Thompson got twisted around and struck the cliff face
several times because of the parachute's pendulum effect. The chute then
collapsed and Thompson fell a significant distance, struck a rock, and
landed in the water. Companions in a recovery boat witnessed the event and
picked him up almost immediately. They said that they'd performed CPR, but
that they were unsuccessful due to severe face, chest, and pelvic trauma.
BASE jumping has not been a problem for Glen Canyon in past years. [Tomie
Lee, CR, GLCA, 9/16]
94-609 - Natural Bridges (Utah) - Burglary
The park's visitor center was burglarized around 8 p.m. on the evening of
October 14th. Thieves broke into a donation box and took about $400, and stole
about $375 worth of books from the cooperating association. A visitor saw two
men in the visitor center at the time of the burglary, but believed they were
cleaning up (no pun intended). One suspect was described as a white male in
his 20s, 5'6" to 5'8" tall, between 160 and 170 pounds, dark hair tied in a
ponytail, and wearing a light blue denim jacket, blue jeans and a dark baseball
cap. The second suspect was also a white male in his 20s, 5'10" to 6'0" tall,
from 160 to 170 pounds, also wearing jeans and a blue jacket. The suspects are
believed to be driving a metallic blue van, possibly a late model. No forced
entry to the visitor center was apparent. [Jim Dougan, CR, NABR, 10/17]
94-528 - Canyonlands (Utah) - Assist on NPS-Related ARPA Arrest
On the morning of October 28th, Canyonlands rangers assisted BLM special agents
and Utah State officers in the execution of a felony arrest warrant on Earl
Shumway for an ARPA violation that occurred the previous week south of the park
on BLM lands. A search warrant of Shumway's property was executed at the time
of his arrest. A loaded weapon, marijuana and drug paraphernalia were found in
his residence. Shumway was charged in 1992 with an ARPA violation within
Canyonlands - a case that is still pending. [Larry Van Slyke, CR, CANY, 10/28]
94-637 - Zion (Utah) - BASE Jumping Arrests
On the afternoon of November 6th, four people were caught BASE jumping off
of Angel's Landing in Zion Canyon. Acting on a tip from Lew Hansen, a
park maintenance employee, rangers Fred Hoeger, Shawn McNally, Beth Martin and
Ed Dunlavey responded to the area and contacted Marta Hewitt, Paul McGreevy,
Frank Le Poole, and Michael Maguire. After multiple interviews, the four
admitted to the jump and were cited under 36 CFR 2.17 (a)(3), air delivery by
parachute. The jumpers subsequently led rangers to four separate locations
where their equipment had been stashed. All equipment was seized pending court
appearances, where forfeiture will be pursued. [David Buccello, Acting CR,
ZION, 11/7]
94-642 - Zion (Utah) - Pursuit and Arrest
On the morning of November 12th, Zion dispatch was given a vehicle and driver
description regarding a recent "gas skip" in a neighboring community. Ranger
Karen Frauson identified the driver as he entered the park, notified patrol,
and requested the standard entrance fee. The driver refused to pay the fee,
stating that he did not recognize federal authority, and drove on. Patrol
ranger John Patmore stopped the vehicle a short time later. The driver, Ryan
C. Bundy of Nevada, refused to identify himself, insisting that the federal
government had no right to stop him and had no authority on Utah lands. Bundy
drove off just as back-up ranger Ed Dunlavey arrived. The two patrol units
began a pursuit of Bundy, who now refused to stop. Bundy continued for a dozen
miles to the park's east entrance, where road spikes were utilized in an
attempt to stop him. Bundy was able to drive around the spikes, narrowly
missing a Utah Highway Patrol officer in the process. He continued out of the
park until stopped by sheriff's deputies at a roadblock about 21 miles from the
point of the initial stop. Bundy was cited for numerous state and federal
charges, including fleeing, interference with agency functions and failure to
pay required fees. Bundy is a member of a local constitutionalist/"wise use"
extremist group which has threatened land management rangers and policies in
the past. [David Buccello, DR, Frontcountry District, ZION, 11/13]
94-644 - Glen Canyon (Utah) - Rescue
On the evening of November 11th, the park received a report of a stranded
climber on a small ledge in Ribbon Canyon. Rescuers responding from Halls
Crossing and Bullfrog worked throughout the night attempting to reach and
rescue Dennis McGlynn of Davis, California, who was perched on a small ledge
about 115 feet above the canyon floor. Night time rescue operations were
hindered by a light rain and poor quality sandstone rock. At first light, a
rescue party consisting of rangers Matt Vandzura and Russ Miller and
maintenance workers Pat Horning and Greg Taylor succeeded in attaining a
position on a higher ledge from which Vandzura was able to traverse across to a
position above McGlynn and from there complete the rescue by lowering him to
the ground. McGlynn spent nearly 19 hours standing on the small ledge. He was
clad in t-shirt, shorts, hiking shoes, and an inexpensive plastic rain poncho.
The latter likely kept him from developing hypothermia. Investigation
following the rescue indicated that McGlynn and his party were BASE jumpers who
have frequently visited remote areas of the park and were all present in the
nearby Escalante Canyon area when Paul Thompson died during a BASE jump in
September. This particular rescue was not related to BASE jumping, however, as
McGlynn was simply free climbing in a narrow side canyon. [Tommie Lee, CR,
GLCA, 11/14]
94-666 - Zion (Utah) - Climbing Fatality
Larry Price, 35, of Crested Butte, Colorado, fell about a hundred feet to his
death while descending from a climb in the Court of the Patriarchs area of the
park around 8 p.m. on November 22nd. The accident was reported by his climbing
partner. The cause of the accident has not been determined, but darkness is
thought to have been a contributing factor. This was the first climbing
related accident to occur in the park in many years. [Denny Davies, ZION,
11/23]
94-682 - Arches (Utah) - Visitor Injured by Ram
On the afternoon of December 15th, a bighorn ram knocked down and injured a
visitor who'd walked into the herd to take photographs. The man had gotten
between the ram and the herd, then had turned his back on the ram and knelt
down to take photos of the rest of the herd. Three smaller rams came to the
front of the group and stared at the man, cocking their heads. When the man
stood up, the large ram charged him, striking him on his right shoulder and
knocking him to the ground. The man got up slowly and began screaming for
help. Two passers-by ran to assist him, but the ram ignored them and charged
again, striking the man in the middle of the back and again knocked him down.
The visitors yelled and waved their arms at the ram, but he stood his ground.
The ram did not charge again, though, and the visitors were able to get the man
back to his car. Although the man suffered a bruise to his shoulder, severe
abrasions on his back and complained of pain around his collar bone, he
declined to report the incident and refused medical assistance offered by one
of the witnesses. According to another of these witnesses, all of the rams
displayed aggressive poses - lowering and cocking their heads - throughout the
incident. This herd is well known in the Moab area because it grazes just off
Utah Highway 191 along the park's southern border during the fall, winter and
early spring. Many visitors stop to take photographs of the animals, but they
usually move up the steep slopes into the park when photographers get too
close. This is the first known instance of a bighorn butting a visitor.
[Karen McKinlay-Jones, ARCH, 12/27]
94-686 - Bryce Canyon (Utah) - MVA with Damage to NPS Structure
Just before noon on December 25th, a 1994 Dodge sedan driven by Yoshiharu
Ishizaki, a Japanese citizen, crashed into the side of the park's west entrance
station. The building's west wall was pushed in about eight inches; the cost
to repair the damage has been estimated at about $5,000. There were no
injuries, as the station was empty at the time and all the occupants of the
vehicle were wearing seatbelts. High speed and icy roads contributed to the
accident. The investigating ranger reported that Ishizaki attempted to pay the
$5 entrance fee as his vehicle was being extracted from the side of the
entrance station. [Charlie Peterson, CR, BRCA, 12/27]
Utah Canyoneering History
Canyoneering USA Homepage