Routes in Zion National ParkRoutes in the San Rafael SwellRoutes in EscalanteRoutes in the Cedar Mesa AreaNorth Wash CanyonsRobbers Roost Canyons
HomepageIntroductionRatingsTech TipsSend me some Feedback

How NOT to do it - a Cautionary Tale (or three)
Adventures in Quandary Canyon
Quandary is a well-known, somewhat technical canyon in the Swell, which seems to draw more than its share of epics. My own experience with Quandary started with meeting the parents of a young woman killed there in a flash flood. Here's a few stories about it, presented to encourage caution in budding young (and old) canyoneers.

Quandary Story #1
• Quandary Story #2
Quandary Story #3
Quandary Story #4 - Bolt Removal Trip


Then I get this email:

hi

i was just looking through your website about some of the canyons you had been through. i started canyoneering in high school as a really impetuous and not very smart kid who loved the desert. well, several years later and some after some tough lessons and soo many close calls i am still hopelessly addicted to a deep tight slot.

actually the reason i felt like writing was because of your quandry canyon story. Last September (1999) me and two of my friends had a similar experience, possibly hanging off of your anchors. Instead of exiting at Allen's suggested point, i decided that since there were anchors placed that meant someone had been through so we pressed on.

while i was reading your description of being stuck in the pot hole my heart stared racing and the adrenalin kickin in as i was thrust back to the moment when the first member of our group slipped on that same rappel and ended up floating in the hole. she was shorter and couldn't reach bottom, so i dropped in to help her unhook, then we both spent 30-45 minutes trying desperately to climb out where you did, we didn't succeed though. hypothermia was setting in and i got scared. since i was the most experienced i couldn't show that though. our other friend, who was still above the pot hole lowered down some webbing and helped pull the first girl out. then he and she both helped pull on me (i'm much bigger though) as i scrambled back up out, i had to heel hook that smaller natural bridge where the old webbing was and do un ugly knee lock to squirm out all shivering and exhausted.

finally, after warming back up and making sure everyone stayed calm, i tied all three backpacks to a long piece of webbing which i secured to my harness, i climbed back up to the anchor, hooked in and then threw the three packs over into the next hole with me attached to give me some leverage on the undercut wall... it didn't help much, but slowly, very slowly, i edged out and squeaked over the lip.

i've had some close calls, but this was one of the closest... perhaps, someone whould go remove that anchor and place a better positioned one, just so more people don't end up stuck in that hole, i think we were both very lucky. maybe we should be responsible to help make sure this doesn't happen again?

just a thought...

myke bybee


Quandary Story #1
• Quandary Story #2
Quandary Story #3
Quandary Story #4 - Bolt Removal Trip



 

Zion | San Rafael Swell | Canyons of the Escalante | Cedar Mesa | North Wash | Robbers Roost
Homepage | Introduction | Ratings | Tech Tips | Feedback
All content © 1996-2005, Canyoneering USA